Switching your dog or cat’s food can feel overwhelming—especially if you’ve heard horror stories of pets suffering from upset stomachs, loose stools, or refusing to eat altogether. At Sam’s Cats and Dogs, we know how much you care about your pet’s health and happiness. Whether you're changing brands, upgrading to a fresh or raw diet, or addressing a specific health concern, making the switch correctly can help avoid digestive issues and set your pet up for long-term wellness. 

Let’s walk through how to safely transition your pet’s food, what to watch for, and natural products that can support a smoother change—like raw goat’s milk and fiber-rich pumpkin or sweet potato. 

 

Why You Might Want to Switch Pet Foods

There are many good reasons to switch your dog or cat’s food: 

  • They’ve developed an allergy or sensitivity 

  • You’re upgrading to a higher-quality or species-appropriate diet 

  • Their life stage has changed (puppy/kitten to adult, adult to senior) 

  • You want to try raw, freeze-dried, or fresh food 

  • Your vet recommends a special formula for health issues 

Regardless of the reason, the key to a successful transition is going slow and supporting the digestive system along the way. 

 

Why Slow and Steady Wins the Race

Unlike humans, your pet’s digestive system thrives on consistency. Sudden changes in diet can overwhelm their gut microbiome, the colony of good bacteria that helps digest food, absorb nutrients, and support immunity. 

Switching food too fast can lead to: 

  • Diarrhea 

  • Vomiting 

  • Gas and bloating 

  • Refusal to eat 

  • Lethargy or discomfort 

To avoid this, always gradually introduce new food over 7–14 days, depending on how sensitive your pet is. 

 

The Ideal Transition Schedule

Here’s a general food-switching schedule that works well for most pets: 

Days 1–3:
75% old food, 25% new food 

Days 4–6:
50% old food, 50% new food 

Days 7–9:
25% old food, 75% new food 

Day 10+:
100% new food 

Tip: If your pet has a sensitive stomach, you can stretch the transition over 2–3 weeks instead. 

If at any point your pet shows signs of digestive distress, pause the transition, return to the previous ratio, and proceed more slowly once they stabilize. 

 

Supporting Digestive Health During a Transition

A smooth transition isn’t just about ratios—it’s also about supporting your pet’s digestive system while it adjusts. Here are some vet- and nutritionist-recommended ways to do that: 

1. Add Digestive Enzymes or Probiotics

These help break down food and balance the gut microbiome. 

At Sam’s Cats and Dogs, we carry natural probiotic supplements and digestive enzyme blends specially formulated for dogs and cats. These are especially helpful if you’re switching to raw or lightly cooked diets. 

 

2. Incorporate Raw Goat’s Milk

Raw goat’s milk is a natural probiotic powerhouse. It’s packed with: 

  • Healthy bacteria to balance gut flora 

  • Enzymes that support digestion 

  • Nutrients that strengthen the immune system 

It's gentle on the stomach and tastes delicious to most pets. You can pour a small amount over your pet’s meal during the transition to help soothe the gut and encourage appetite. 

Available at Sam’s: Ask us about our trusted brands of raw goat’s milk for dogs and cats! 

 

3. Use Natural Fiber Sources Like Pumpkin and Sweet Potato

Fiber helps firm up stools and regulate digestion during diet changes. 

  • Plain pumpkin (unsweetened, canned) is rich in soluble fiber and helps with both diarrhea and constipation. 

  • Cooked or dehydrated sweet potato is gentle on the stomach and adds prebiotic fiber that supports healthy gut bacteria. 

Add a spoonful to each meal during the transition. We stock fiber blends and single-ingredient toppers made from real pumpkin and sweet potato. 

 

4. Hydrate with Bone Broth or Water-Rich Foods

If you’re switching from dry kibble to canned, raw, or fresh food, hydration plays a key role. 

  • Adding bone broth to meals provides minerals and collagen for gut lining support. 

  • Transitioning to wet or raw food naturally adds more moisture to your pet’s diet, aiding digestion and nutrient absorption. 

Look for low-sodium, pet-safe broths or consult our team at Sam’s for high-quality options. 

 

Signs Your Pet Is Struggling With the Transition

Even with the best preparation, some pets may experience mild issues. Here’s what to look out for: 

  • Loose stools lasting more than 2–3 days 

  • Lethargy or refusal to eat 

  • Vomiting more than once 

  • Excessive scratching or licking (possible food sensitivity) 

If you notice these symptoms, slow the transition and consider adding digestive supports like goat’s milk, pumpkin, or probiotics. If symptoms persist, consult your veterinarian. 

 

What If You’re Switching to Raw or Fresh Food?

Switching to raw or gently cooked diets is a growing trend among pet parents looking to mimic a more natural, species-appropriate way of feeding. These diets often contain fewer fillers, preservatives, and artificial ingredients—but they can be a big change for your pet’s system. 

When switching to raw or fresh food: 

  • Stick to single-protein recipes at first 

  • Avoid introducing too many new ingredients at once 

  • Use probiotics, goat’s milk, and fiber as needed to support the transition 

  • Monitor stool quality, energy levels, and appetite closely 

We’re happy to help you choose a starter raw or fresh food at Sam’s Cats and Dogs that fits your pet’s size, breed, and lifestyle. 

 

Additional Tips for a Successful Transition

  • Don’t mix raw and kibble in the same meal unless guided by a nutritionist, as they digest at different rates 

  • Use a feeding log to track food amounts and stool quality 

  • Keep treats minimal during the transition to avoid overwhelming the gut 

  • Give your pet time—some may take longer than others to fully adapt 

 

Ask the Experts at Sam’s Cats and Dogs

Every pet is different, and what works for one may not work for another. Our team at Sam’s Cats and Dogs is here to help you find: 

  • The right transition-friendly foods for your dog or cat 

  • Raw goat’s milk, fiber-rich toppers, and probiotic supplements 

  • Customized plans for transitioning to raw, cooked, freeze-dried, or special diets 

We believe in education-first support—so you can make the best decisions for your pet without pressure. 

 

Changing your pet’s food doesn’t have to be stressful. With a gradual approach and the right support products like raw goat’s milk, pumpkin, and sweet potato, you can help your dog or cat thrive through the transition and beyond. 

For help choosing the best food for your pet—or to stock up on gut-friendly supplements and toppers—stop by Sam’s Cats and Dogs or reach out to our knowledgeable staff. We’re happy to answer questions and guide you every step of the way.